Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant

4.5 ( 703 reviews )
Checking... 12:00 AM - 8:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
2885 Main St, Newfane, NY 14108, United States
+1 716-778-9069
Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant, nestled in the heart of Newfane, NY, is a beloved gem offering a delightful mix of traditional and innovative Italian cuisine. Family-owned for over 50 years, Cafora's prides itself on its warm, welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service. Reviewers highlight the vast menu, from mouthwatering pizzas to generous pasta dishes, all at reasonable prices. Diners rave about the thin-crust pizza, cooked to perfection, and the standout spinach garlic bread appetizer that elevates the dining experience. The Buffalo Chicken Salad and hearty Chicken Parmesan are also crowd favorites, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients. Customer service receives consistent praise, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit. Unique offerings like the "Chubby Challenge" add a fun twist for adventurous eaters, further enhancing its charm. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Cafora's proves to be a must-visit culinary stop. With its delicious food, friendly ambiance, and dedicated service, it's no surprise that patrons are willing to travel long distances just to savor a meal here. Truly, Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant embodies the heart of Italian dining with every bite.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Has fast service
    • Has great wine list
  • Popular for
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
    • Good for solo dining
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves cocktails
    • Serves coffee
    • Serves comfort food
    • Quick bite
    • Serves small plates
    • Serves wine
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Has catering
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • Has toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Good for groups
    • Popular with tourists
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs available
    • Has kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant

mike branch
May 12,2025
We came in with a large party for Mother's Day. We came early, when the doors opened. We all ordered dinner entrees. We had small children with us. The food was excellent . The spinach garlic bread appetizer was superb. Our waitress was the best...couldn't ask for better. Thanks for the great food and service!
Brynna Malen
Mar 8,2025
If you live or visit anywhere within driving distance to Newfane, I STRONGLY recommend you stop in for a meal at Cafora's! They have a vast and extensive menu full of classic and original Italian meals! Family owned and ran for 50 years. Charming and quaint environment with extremely reasonable prices! They even have a "CHUBBY CHALLENGE". If you can eat an entire Chubby in 30 minutes or less you can win a 10 gift certificate AND get on the Wall Of Shame!!! I definitely will be coming in regularly to try more menu items! Lourie was a friendly and fun server who recommended an amazing meal for me.
Rickylee Smith
Mar 2,2025
Pretty consistent and a lot of great tasting items on there menu. There thin style pizza cooked well done is one of my favorite pizzas
D C
Feb 27,2025
I’ve been a customer for many years and my husband is a die hard fan of their pizza so anytime we are in newfane we order a large to take home. Always polite, quick and delicious!
Dave Jurenko
Feb 25,2025
My family and I travel an hour and a half just to come here to eat. They have great food. Big portions. The waitress are always friendly and the place is always clean. We have 5 people in our family and we never have to wait long to be seated. My wife had the chicken parmesan, our 2 girls had the spaghetti and meatballs, my son had the pizza and fries and I had a steak pazone. Everything was delicious and the prices are reasonable.
Karen Dunch
Feb 19,2025
My husband and I always enjoy the food, wait staff and the atmosphere. I recommend the restaurant highly.
Gangesh Yadav
Feb 12,2025
Have visited this place thrice and it has been awesome all the time. Delicious food with great serving size and warm welcome staff makes you feel like home. Accommodate people with special food requests. They have pizza theatre where you can watch cook making pizza. Order comes with warm bread and it is best tasting bread that i have ever tasted.
Betsy Wisto
Feb 11,2025
Great food reasonably priced and very large portions. Service was great and extremely friendly. It's comfort food at it's best. I have yet to try the pizza and wings but I'm looking forward to it. Every person I've met who has been there before has nothing but good things to say. I'm in total agreement. Also the homemade bread is outstanding.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Fried Fish Shack
(158 review)
Fried Fish Shack
  • 826 Joseph Ave, Rochester, NY 14621, United States
Fish & chips restaurant
+1 585-434-0518
Maki Sushi Bar & Bistro
(810 review)
Maki Sushi Bar & Bistro
  • 126 N Main St, Anderson, SC 29621, United States
Sushi restaurant
+1 864-642-6440
Reserva Coffee Roasters
(131 review)
Reserva Coffee Roasters
  • 4217 N McColl Rd #1200, McAllen, TX 78504, United States
Coffee shop
+1 956-625-2233
Meltdown London
(655 review)
Meltdown London
  • 342 Caledonian Rd, London N1 1BB, United Kingdom
Bar
Tavern Law 1832
(253 review)
Tavern Law 1832
  • 106 N 2nd St, Wilmington, NC 28401, United States
Bar
+1 910-769-9340
HometownLocker Room Pizza & Subs
(172 review)
HometownLocker Room Pizza & Subs
  • 117 S Main St #1, St Marys, OH 45885, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 419-394-0130
Number 1 Chinese Restaurant
(256 review)
Number 1 Chinese Restaurant
  • 2029 Lynnhaven Pkwy #250, Virginia Beach, VA 23456, United States
Chinese restaurant
+1 757-416-1888
The Brothers Beer & Bourbon House
(193 review)
The Brothers Beer & Bourbon House
  • 3880 S Lindbergh Blvd Ste 300, St. Louis, MO 63127, United States
Bar
+1 314-756-2039
Harlequin Coffee House & Tea Room, Cafe
(284 review)
Harlequin Coffee House & Tea Room, Cafe
  • 2b King's Sq, York YO1 8BH, United Kingdom
Coffee shop
+44 1904 630631
Kolamba East - Sri Lankan Restaurant Liverpool Street
(182 review)
Kolamba East - Sri Lankan Restaurant Liverpool Street
  • 12 Blossom St, London E1 6PL, United Kingdom
Asian restaurant
+44 20 3435 7174